3 minute read

Abbreviations, acronyms, initialisms, portmanteaux.

If a graduate student uses some type of software to string together (or edit?) words, does the student need permission and, if so, from whom?

There are probably norms, expectations, and practices common within each discipline and that differ between disciplines. Oral vs written PhD comps. Number of research chapters in a thesis. To some extend departments, programs, and universities impose structures here.

But with respect to GenAI/LLM/whatever use, this could vary widely between universities.

“Graduate students must have endorsement from their advisor(s) and committee for the utilization of generative AI in their research and/or writing.” Student Responsibilities{.uri}, Laurier

“Advisors (and advisory committees) should provide clear guidance and expectations on what degree of engagement with generative AI in research and/or writing is acceptable (if any). Collectively, the advisor, advisory committee, and graduate student should develop processes by which a student can attest to their own contributions (e.g., during research updates provided at committee meetings), while also noting how the use of generative AI tools contributed to their work.” Advisor Responsibilities{.uri}, Laurier

There is nothing on the committee forms for master’s or PhD students that would remind the committee to have this discussion or to remind everyone that it’s not up to the advisor alone. If one committee member disagrees do they get removed from the committee?

“For research, graduate students should consult with their supervisor(s) and advisory committee (if one exists) about the limit and scope of the use of GenAI tools, which is often discipline-dependent. Permitted uses and expectations for using GenAI tools should be communicated between the students and their supervisor(s).” Guidance for graduate students and supervisors, Waterloo

“Since norms regarding the use of generative AI technologies vary across academic disciplines, graduate students who plan to use generative AI tools in researching or writing, including the completion of the Qualifying Examination, must seek unambiguous approval for planned uses in advance from their advisor(s) and advisory committee.  Approvals must be documented and adhere to departmental and/or field-specific policies where they exist.” Guidance on the use of Generative AI for Graduate Students, their Advisors, and Graduate Programs, Guelph

“The use of generative AI tools in any aspect of researching or writing of the thesis must be done with the prior approval of the supervisor(s) and supervisory committee.” & “Graduate units and individual supervisors who embrace the use of generative AI tools in research methods may still wish to restrict the use of such tools in other aspects of writing or editing papers or theses. There must be clear guidance for graduate students on what degree of engagement with generative AI in writing is acceptable (if any).” Guidance on the Appropriate Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence for Graduate Academic Milestones, Toronto

“For research, scholarship, and creative activities, the use of generative AI should be discussed with the supervisor(s) and supervisory committee.” Guidance for the use of Generative AI in Graduate Studies, Western

“This section must include a high-level overview of the use or non-use of Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) in the thesis. Non-use of AI should be stated explicitly.” Formatting: Structural Requirements, Style Guidelines, and Templates, Western

So, advisors and committees seem to have some veto power. Do they know this? Probably not. Are they willing to use it? Probably not. 🤷🏽

There is a lot of should, no shall, and must is reserved for students. 🤷🏽

From the Ontario Council on Graduate Studies (October 2024):

  • How are academics approaching the use of generative AI in graduate studies so far?

  • Perceptions on the use and value of generative AI for graduate studies understandably vary, often significantly, among individuals, academic disciplinary cultures, and institutional settings. In some disciplines, where machine learning has a longer history, there is broader understanding of the capabilities and limitations of AI, as well as recognition of the strengths of this technology for solving problems that were previously intractable. In other disciplines, AI calls to the fore questions of ethical engagement and social and environmental responsibilities.

  • Given the capabilities of generative AI, should graduate degree level expectations or the values of graduate research change?

  • No.

  • Given the capabilities of generative AI, should program learning outcomes, scope of graduate research, or graduate research activities change?

  • Yes.

E-I-E-I-O, Ostanek.

Updated: